Court dismisses case against nursing home worker over Covid outbreak in Sant Joan les Fonts

The Provincial Court of Girona finds no evidence of criminal liability in the deaths of seven residents during 2021.

Generic image of a judge's gavel on a wooden table in a courtroom.
IA

Generic image of a judge's gavel on a wooden table in a courtroom.

The Provincial Court of Girona has officially closed the investigation into a nursing home worker in Sant Joan les Fonts following a fatal Covid-19 outbreak in 2021.

The court dismissed an appeal filed by a victim's family, ruling that there is insufficient evidence to proceed with criminal charges. The case, which lasted five years, investigated the circumstances surrounding the deaths of seven residents at a facility managed by the Suara cooperative.
Judges upheld a previous ruling from the Olot court, noting that reports from the Mossos d'Esquadra police force could not prove the employee was the sole source of the infection. Furthermore, the worker had tested negative in a PCR test conducted by the center during the period in question.

"There was no crime or sufficient evidence for a procedure that has had a deep personal and professional impact."

Mònica Vilar · Defense Lawyer
The defense argued that the worker's symptoms were consistent with a chronic cough she had suffered for over a year. This legal victory follows a separate labor court ruling in Girona which had already declared her dismissal from the nursing home as unfair.