Prosecution backs dismissal of Catalan language discrimination case at Clínica Diagonal

The prosecutor considers it reasonable for a doctor to request a patient speak Spanish to ensure medical safety.

Generic image of a wooden gavel in a courtroom.
IA

Generic image of a wooden gavel in a courtroom.

The Barcelona prosecutor's office has supported the court's decision to archive a complaint against a doctor at Clínica Diagonal who allegedly refused to treat a patient in Catalan.

The case involves Gerard Insa, a teacher who reported linguistic discrimination during a medical visit in Esplugues de Llobregat. Prosecutor Antonio Vicén Banzo argued that the doctor's request for the patient to speak Spanish was 'necessary' to avoid incorrect diagnoses, even if it 'hurt the patient's linguistic sensitivity'.

"The conduct of the doctor... seems reasonable, and even necessary."

Antonio Vicén Banzo · Prosecutor
The legal group Acció Cassandra has appealed to the Audiencia de Barcelona, claiming a violation of constitutional rights. They argue that the case should be investigated as a hate crime under the Spanish Penal Code and have threatened to take the matter to the European Court of Human Rights if the dismissal is upheld.